The Ratchet Effect in Performance Target Setting: A Literature Review

Yu Yuan

doi:10.54097/vd6ga872

Authors

Yu Yuan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/vd6ga872

Keywords:

Performance Target; Ratchet Effect; Target Ratcheting; Literature Review.

Abstract

Performance target setting is one of the core issues in the design of incentive contract, while the ratchet effect is among the most important and extensively discussed areas in goal setting research. This paper reviews relevant studies from three perspectives: the existence of target ratcheting, the causes and impacts of target ratcheting, and the influencing factors of target ratcheting. It focuses on evaluating the influencing factors that mitigate the impact of the ratchet effect in target setting. By organizing and summarizing existing research findings, this paper aims to assist researchers in advancing studies related to performance targets and identifying potential research gaps in target ratcheting.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Indjejikian R J, Matějka M, Schloetzer J D. Target Ratcheting and Incentives: Theory, Evidence, and New Opportunities[J]. The Accounting Review, 2014, 89(4): 1259-1267.

[2] Feichter C, Grabner I, Moers F. Target Setting in Multi-Divisional Firms: State of the Art and Avenues for Future Research[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2018, 30(3): 29-54.

[3] Indjejikian R J, Matějka M, Merchant K A, et al. Earnings Targets and Annual Bonus Incentives[J]. The Accounting Review, 2014, 89(4): 1227-1258.

[4] Aranda C, Arellano J, Davila A. Ratcheting and the Role of Relative Target Setting[J]. The Accounting Review, 2014, 89(4): 1197-1226.

[5] Bol J C, Lill J B. Performance Target Revisions in Incentive Contracts: Do Information and Trust Reduce Ratcheting and the Ratchet Effect?[J]. The Accounting Review, 2015, 90(5): 1755-1778.

[6] Casas‐Arce P, Holzhacker M, Mahlendorf M D, et al. Relative Performance Evaluation and the Ratchet Effect[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2018, 35(4): 1702-1731.

[7] Berliner J S. Factory and Manager in the USSR[M]. Harvard University Press, 1957: 88-113.

[8] Weitzman M L. The New Soviet Incentive Model[J]. The Bell Journal of Economics, 1976, 7(1): 251-257.

[9] Weitzman M L. The “Ratchet Principle” and Performance Incentives[J]. The Bell Journal of Economics, 1980, 11(1): 302.

[10] Yunker J A. A Dynamic Optimization Model of the Soviet Enterprise[J]. Economics of Planning, 1973, 13(1-2): 33-51.

[11] Murrell P. The Performance of Multiperiod Managerial Incentive Schemes[J]. The American Economic Review, 1979, 69(5): 934-940.

[12] Granick D. The Ministry as the Maximizing Unit in Soviet Industry[J]. Journal of Comparative Economics, 1980, 4(3): 255-273.

[13] Liu C N. The Ratchet Principle: A Diagrammatic Interpretation[J]. Journal of Comparative Economics, 1982, 6(1): 75-80.

[14] Wei Sen. Ratchet Effect and Dynamic Behavior of Agents [J]. Economic Science, 1998(6): 27-36.

[15] Xu Siyang, Liu Meizi. Ratchet Effect of Chinese Commercial Banks' Incentive System and their Operational Risks [J]. Financial Economics Research, 2017, 32(5): 82-93.

[16] Cooper D J, Kagel J H, Lo W, et al. Gaming against Managers in Incentive Systems: Experimental Results with Chinese Students and Chinese Managers[J]. American Economic Review, 1999, 89(4): 781-804.

[17] Charness G, Kuhn P, Villeval M C. Competition and the Ratchet Effect[J]. Journal of Labor Economics, 2011, 29(3): 513-547.

[18] Cardella E, Depew B. Output Restriction and the Ratchet Effect: Evidence from A Real-effort Work Task[J]. Games and Economic Behavior, 2018, 107: 182-202.

[19] Arnold M C, Artz M, Tafkov I D. The Effect of Past Performance and Task Type on Managers’ Target Setting Decisions: An Experimental Investigation[J]. The Accounting Review, 2022, 97(7): 1-22.

[20] Kim S, Shin J Y. Executive Bonus Target Ratcheting: Evidence from the New Executive Compensation Disclosure Rules[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2017, 34(4): 1843-1879.

[21] Wei Chunyan. State Ownership and Target Setting: Evidence from Publicly Listed Companies in China[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2021, 38(3).

[22] Kim S, Matějka M, Park J. Economic Determinants and Consequences of Performance Target Difficulty[J]. The Accounting Review, 2023, 98(2): 361-387.

[23] Matějka M. Target Setting in Multi-Divisional Organizations[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2018, 30(3): 13-27.

[24] Balakrishnan R, Huang J, Wu A. Target Setting in a Multi-Task Environment: An Empirical Investigation[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2022, 34(3): 11-28.

[25] Kuroki M, Shuto A. Budget Ratcheting and Debtholders’ Monitoring: Evidence from Private Colleges and Universities[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2022, 34(2): 163-179.

[26] Sewerin S, Fesenfeld L P, Schmidt T S. The Role of Policy Design in Policy Continuation and Ratcheting-up of Policy Ambition[J]. Policy and Society, 2023, 42(4): 478-492.

[27] Matějka M, Mahlendorf M D, Schäffer U. The Ratchet Effect: Theory and Empirical Evidence[J]. Management Science, 2022.

[28] Murphy K J. Performance Standards in Incentive Contracts[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2000, 30(3): 245-278.

[29] Dekker H C, Groot T, Schoute M. Determining Performance Targets[J]. Behavioral Research in Accounting, 2012, 24(2): 21-46.

[30] Leone A J, Rock S. Empirical Tests of Budget Ratcheting and Its Effect on Managers’ Discretionary Accrual Choices[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2002, 33(1): 43-67.

[31] Choi B H, Kim S J, Merchant K A. Firms’ Commitment to Mitigate the Ratchet Effect under Annual Bonus Plans with Multiple Performance Measures[J]. SSRN Electronic Journal, 2012.

[32] Mei Shiqiang, Wei Haoqiang. Research on the Relationship of Ratchet Effect and Earnings Management [J]. Science Research Management, 2014, 35(8): 101-109.

[33] Milgrom P R, Roberts J, Roberts J. Economics, organization and management | Wageningen University and Research Library catalog[M]. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-hall, 1992.

[34] Bouwens J, Kroos P. Target Ratcheting and Effort Reduction[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2011, 51(1): 171-185.

[35] Dai Lu, Song Di. The Influence of Mandatory Requirement of Performance Hurdles in Executive Equity Incentive Contracts on Corporate Management Performance [J]. China Industrial Economics, 2018(4): 117-136.

[36] Chow C W, Cooper J C, Haddad K. The Effects of Pay Schemes and Ratchets on Budgetary Slack and Performance: A Multiperiod Experiment[J]. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 1991, 16(1): 47-60.

[37] Indjejikian R, Nanda D. Dynamic Incentives and Responsibility Accounting[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 1999, 27(2): 177-201.

[38] Hwang I, Kim Y, Lim M K. Optimal Ratcheting in Executive Compensation[J]. Decision Analysis, 2023, 20(2): 166-185.

[39] Meyer M A, Vickers J. Performance Comparisons and Dynamic Incentives[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1997, 105(3): 547-581.

[40] Xiao Jihui, Peng Wenping. Ratchet Effect of Compensation and the Choice of Relative Performance Evaluation [J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2010, 7(7): 993-999.

[41] Wang Xuelian, Liu Bing. Research on Ratchet Effects of Incentive on the Enterprise's Manager [J]. Industrial Engineering Journal, 2007(4): 7-11.

[42] Kanemoto Y, MacLeod W B. The Ratchet Effect and the Market for Secondhand Workers[J]. Journal of Labor Economics, 1992, 10(1): 85-98.

[43] Xiang Weixing, Fu Liwen. The Ratchet Effect in the Incentive Mechanisms of State-Owned Commercial Banks [J]. Social Science Front, 2006(3): 273-277.

[44] Deore A, Mahlendorf M D, Wu F. Ceos’ Structural Power, Prestige Power, and Target Ratcheting[J]. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 2023, 110: 101469.

[45] Cui Jianbo, Luo Zhengying. Cost Control and Ratchet Effect:Sharing Saving Incentive Mechanism vs.Target Incentive Mechanism [J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2023, 31(8): 90-99.

[46] Oh S. Product Market Competition and Target Ratcheting[J]. Applied Economics Letters, 2024, 0(0): 1-5.

[47] Baron D P, Besanko D. Regulation and information in a continuing relationship[J]. Information Economics and Policy, 1984, 1(3): 267-302.

[48] Aranda C, Arellano J, Davila A. Subjective Bonuses and Target Setting in Budget-Based Incentive Contracts[J]. Management Accounting Research, 2019, 43: 45-60.

[49] Bouwens J, Hofmann C, Schwaiger N. Target Setting in Hierarchies: The Role of Middle Managers[J]. Journal of Accounting Research, 2024, 62(1): 375-410.

[50] Ickes B W, Samuelson L. Job Transfers and Incentives in Complex Organizations: Thwarting the Ratchet Effect[J]. The RAND Journal of Economics, 1987, 18(2): 275-286.

[51] Arya A, Mittendorf B. Using Job Rotation to Extract Employee Information[J]. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 2004, 20(2): 400-414.

[52] Wei C. Can Job Rotation Eliminate the Ratchet Effect: Experimental Evidence[J]. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2020, 180: 66-84.

[53] Zhen Hongxian, Wang Xi, Shi Yongdong. Research on the Phenomenon of Corporate Performance Cluster: Based on the Regression Discontinuity Design of the Equity Incentive Programs of Chinese A-share Listed Companies [J]. Journal of Management World, 2021, 37(6): 159-172+10.

[54] Li L Y, Wang S, Zhu W. Operating Cash Flows and Earnings Target Revision: Evidence from Annual Cash Bonus Plans for CEOs[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2022, 34(2): 181-199.

[55] Choi S, Kim S, Kwon S, et al. Analyst Forecasts and Target Setting in Executive Annual Bonus Contracts[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 2021, 33(2): 19-42.

[56] Liu Mengning, Liu Yunguo. Economic Policy Uncertainty, Business Target Setting and Ratcheting [J]. Accounting Research, 2022(7): 89-106.

[57] Verhoef P C, Broekhuizen T, Bart Y, et al. Digital transformation: A multidisciplinary reflection and research agenda[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2021, 122: 889-901.