The Impact of Corporate Earnings Smoothing on Trade Credit Financing

Yixuan Chen

doi:10.54097/j3x3v580

Authors

Yixuan Chen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/j3x3v580

Keywords:

earnings smoothing, commercial credit financing, legal environment, social trustv.

Abstract

Based on data from A-share listed companies in China between 2008 and 2023, this paper examines the impact of earnings smoothing on trade credit financing and its underlying mechanisms. The findings reveal that earnings smoothing significantly enhances firms' access to trade credit by reducing earnings volatility, mitigating information asymmetry, and signaling operational stability to suppliers. Further analysis indicates that informative earnings smoothing has a positive effect on trade credit financing, whereas opportunistic earnings smoothing shows no significant influence. Additionally, the legal environment and social trust negatively moderate this relationship, suggesting that the positive effect of earnings smoothing weakens in regions with stronger institutional frameworks.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Ge Y, Qiu J. Financial development, bank discrimination and trade credit[J]. Journal of Banking & Finance, 2007,31(2):513-530.

[2] Wang Yanchao. Financial inhibition and the secondary allocation function of commercial credit[J]. Journal of Banking & Finance, 2007,31(2):513-530., 2014,49(06):86-99.

[3] Gordon M J. Postulates, principles and research in accounting[J]. The Accounting Review, 1964,39(2):251.

[4] Zhong Yuxiang, Li Wanli. Surplus information and the risk of stock price collapse - a decomposition test based on earnings smoothing[J]. Journal of Management Science, 2019,22(08):88-107.

[5] Burgstahler D C, Hail L, Leuz C. The importance of reporting incentives: earnings management in European private and public firms[J]. The accounting review, 2006,81(5):983-1016.

[6] Ewert R, Wagenhofer A. Economic relations among earnings quality measures[J]. Abacus, 2015,51(3):311-355.

[7] Zhang Jing, Wang Sengnian. earnings smoothing, heterogeneous investor beliefs and asset mispricing-An analysis based on2000-2012 data from China's Shanghai and Shenzhen markets[J]. Business Research, 2017(09):53-59.

[8] Bi Xiaofang, Liu Shengyong, Xing Xiaohui. Does earnings smoothing Affect R&D Staff Stability? --A Study of Mechanisms and Economic Consequences[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2023:1-31.

[9] Lu Zhengfei, Yang Deming. Commercial Credit: Alternative Financing, or Buyer's Market? [J]. Management World, 2011(04):6-14.

[10] Huang Xingjing, Deng Lu, Qu You. Monetary policy, commercial credit and corporate investment behaviour[J]. Accounting Research, 2016(02):58-65.

[11] Fabbri D, Klapper L F. Bargaining power and trade credit[J]. Journal of corporate finance, 2016,41:66-80.

[12] Peng Ziqian, Zhou Peng. A study on the impact of digital transformation on commercial credit financing ability, based on the perspective of supply chain information transfer[J]. Management Modernisation, 2023,43(01):82-90.

[13] He Weifeng, Liu Wei. The managerial effect in commercial credit: A perspective based on managerial competence[J]. Accounting Research, 2018(02):48-54.

[14] Liu Li, Hu Wenxiu, Wang Fangyun. The impact of CEO financial background on business credit financing: the mediating effect of overconfidence[J]. Enterprise Economics, 2022,41(07):149-160.

[15] Hu Jun, Dai Ming, HU Qianqian. Directors and Officers Liability Insurance and Corporate Business Credit[J]. Financial Theory and Practice, 2019,40(05):62-68.

[16] Tucker J W, Zarowin P A. Does income smoothing improve earnings informativeness?[J]. The accounting review, 2006,81(1):251-270.

[17] Chen Bo, Chen Bang. A Review of Research on Earnings Smoothing Behaviour of Listed Companies[J]. Accounting Forum, 2013,12(01):78-88.

[18] Leuz C, Nanda D, Wysocki P D. Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison[J]. Journal of financial economics, 2003,69(3):505-527.

[19] Demerjian P, Donovan J, Lewis Western M F. Income smoothing and the usefulness of earnings for monitoring in debt contracting[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2020,37(2):857-884.

[20] Khurana I K, Pereira R, Zhang E. Is real earnings smoothing harmful? Evidence from firm-specific stock price crash risk[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2018,35(1):558-587.

[21] Spagnolo G. Managerial incentives and collusive behaviour[J]. European Economic Review, 2005.

[22] Acharya V V, Lambrecht B M. A Theory of Income Smoothing When Insiders Know More Than Outsiders[J]. The review of financial studies, 2015,28(9):2534-2574.

[23] Rountree B, Weston J P, Allayannis G. Do investors value smooth performance?[J]. Journal of Financial Economics, 2008,90(3):237-251.

[24] Beidleman C R. Income smoothing: The role of management[J]. The Accounting review, 1973,48(4):653-667.

[25] Amiram D, Owens E. Sign reversal in the relationship between income smoothing and cost of debt[J]. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 2018,45.

[26] Lang M, Lins K V, Maffett M. Transparency, liquidity, and valuation: international evidence on when transparency matters most[J]. Journal of Accounting Research, 2012,50(3):729-774.

[27] Bi Xiaofang, Xing Xiaohui, Wang Lele. The impact of CEOs with technology background on corporate earnings smoothing[J]. Science Decision Making, 2022(04):44-61.

[28] Schwartz R A. An economic model of trade credit[J]. Journal of financial and quantitative analysis, 1974,9(4):643-657.

[29] Li Zeguang, Qin Jiaqi. Financing constraints and liquidity provision in the commercial credit channel-a study based on the perspective of firm heterogeneity[J]. Nankai Journal (Philosophy and Social Science Edition).), 2020(06):59-70.

[30] Rao Pinggui, Jiang Guohua. The Impact of Monetary Policy on the Interaction between Bank Credit and Commercial Credit[J]. Economic Research, 2013,48(01):68-82.

[31] Lu Zhengfei, Zhu Jigao, FAN Zheng. Banking Tightening, Credit Discrimination and Loss of Investors' Interests in Privately Listed Companies[J]. Financial Research, 2009(08):124-136.

[32] LI Shuangjian, LI Junqing, ZHANG Yun. Social Trust, Commercial Credit Financing and Enterprise Innovation[J]. Nankai Economic Research, 2020(03):81-102.

[33] Zhang Xinmin, Wang Jue, Zhu Jigao. Market Position, Commercial Credit and Business Financing[J]. Accounting Research, 2012(08):58-65.

[34] Zhou Liyuan, Wu Le, Cui Rui. How does innovation ability affect the acquisition of business credit? [J]. Finance and Economy, 2020(08):81-88.

[35] Fang Mingyue. Market Competition, Financial Constraints and Business Credit: An Empirical Analysis Based on Chinese Manufacturing Firms[J]. Financial Research, 2014(02):111-124.

[36] Zhang Zhengyong, Deng Bofu. Corporate Social Responsibility, Monetary Policy and Business Credit Financing[J]. Research Management, 2018,39(05):94-102.

[37] Zheng Chaoyu, Meng Xianghui. Corporate Reputation, Market Competition and Commercial Credit Financing: An Empirical Examination Based on Chinese Listed Companies[J]. Dongyue Lecture Series, 2021,42(01):98-106.

[38] Fang Hongxing, Chu Youwei. Corporate Strategy and Commercial Credit Financing[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2019,22(05):142-154.

[39] Sun Jie, Li Minghui. Gains and Losses on Asset Sales of Listed Companies and Commercial Credit Financing[J]. Journal of Zhongnan University of Economics and Law, 2021(02):3-16.

[40] Gao Lifang, Lin Mengchun, You Jiaxing. "Charting and Crediting"? A study on the relationship between visual annual report disclosure and commercial credit financing[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2025:1-25.

[41] Healy P M, Wahlen J M. A review of the earnings management literature and its implications for standard setting[J]. Accounting horizons, 1999,13(4):365-383.

[42] Li LaiFang, Zhang WeiHua, Lu QiRui. The impact of accounting information quality on debt financing of private enterprises: A monetary policy perspective[J]. Accounting Research, 2018(04):66-72.

[43] Qi Yudong, Xiao Xu. Enterprise management change in the era of digital economy[J]. Management World, 2020,36(06):135-152.

[44] Chen Hong, Chen Yuxiu, Yang Yanwen. Off-balance sheet liabilities and accounting information quality, business credit: An empirical study based on the perspective of off-balance sheet liabilities monitoring of listed companies[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2014,17(01):69-75.

[45] Hu Yue, Wu Wenfeng. Commercial Credit Financing and the Structural Problems of Corporate Debt in China[J]. Economics (Quarterly)), 2022,22(01):257-280.

[46] Cunat V. Trade credit: suppliers as debt collectors and insurance providers[J]. The Review of Financial Studies, 2007,20(2):491-527.

[47] Bradshaw M T, Sloan R G. GAAP versus the street: an empirical assessment of two alternative definitions of earnings[J]. Journal of accounting research, 2002,40(1):41-66.

[48] Wang Xiongyuan, Peng Xuan, Wang Peng. Monetary policy, stable customer relationships and strong buyer's commercial credit[J]. Financial Research, 2015(06):31-40.

[49] Kalwani M U, Narayandas N. Long-term manufacturer-supplier relationships: do they pay off for supplier firms?[J]. Journal of marketing, 1995,59(1):1-16.

[50] Zhang Yong. Do supply chain relational transactions induce firms to classify transfer surplus management behaviour? [J]. Securities Market Herald, 2017(07):43-51.

[51] Shu Wei, Chen Ying. Digital Transformation and Business Credit Financing Behaviour of Enterprises[J]. Accounting Research, 2024(01):79-93.

[52] Lang M, Raedy J S, Wilson W. Earnings management and cross listing: Are reconciled earnings comparable to US earnings? Journal of accounting and economics, 2006,42(1-2):255-283.

[53] Wang Fang, Zhang Yufeng, LI Ying. Accounting information relevance and corporate innovation[J]. Economic Issues, 2022(07):88-94.

[54] You Jiaxing, Li Bin. Information Transparency and Corporate Governance Efficiency: Empirical Evidence from Changes in General Managers of Listed Companies in China[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2007(04):73-79.

[55] Dechow P, Ge W, Schrand C. Understanding earnings quality: a review of the proxies, their determinants and their consequences[J]. Journal of accounting and economics, 2010,50(2-3):344-401.

[56] Sumiadji S, Chandrarin G, Subiyantoro E. Effect of audit quality on earnings quality: evidence from Indonesia stock exchange[J]. International Journal of Financial Research., 2019,10(1):86-97.

[57] Pan Yue, Xie Yuxiang, Ning Bo, et al. Empowerment of Digital Intelligence, Rule of Law Business Environment Construction and Commercial Credit Financing: Empirical Evidence from the Perspective of "Smart Court"[J]. Management World, 2022,38(09):194-208.

[58] Brown J R, Martinsson G, Petersen B C. Law, stock markets, and innovation[J]. The Journal of Finance, 2013,68(4):1517-1549.

[59] Han MeiNi, Wang FuSheng. Rule of law environment, financial information and innovation performance[J]. Nankai Management Review, 2016,19(05):28-40.

[60] Gu Leilei, Wang Hongyu. Social trust, financing constraints and corporate innovation[J]. The Economist, 2020(11):39-50.